Goodreads alternatives: an honest comparison

November 2026 ยท written by the makers of Ribbon, so read it with that in mind

There is no single best book tracker. They differ mainly on three things: how social they are, how much they know about you, and what they cost. Here is a fair look at the main choices, including ours.

We describe each service in general terms and do not rely on details that change often. Features and prices change, so check the current version of any app before you decide.

Goodreads

Strong at: size. It is the biggest reader network, so your friends are probably already there, and it has a huge catalogue, reviews from other readers, lists and challenges. It is the default place to see what other people thought of a book.

Worth knowing: it is social by design, it shows ads and recommendations, and it requires an account. Many readers who leave want something quieter, not something bigger. You can export your library as a CSV, so leaving is possible.

The StoryGraph

Strong at: reading statistics and recommendations. It is known for charts about your reading and for describing books by mood and pace rather than only by genre. It can import a Goodreads export.

Worth knowing: it is also an account-based online service, and the recommendations depend on the data you give it. Good if you like insight into your habits; less so if you want nothing leaving your phone.

Bookmory

Strong at: reading as a habit. It is a mobile app built around logging reading sessions and seeing your stats, with a timer-style approach to tracking time.

Worth knowing: it focuses on the tracking side more than on community. Check its current account and pricing options, as they can change.

Fable

Strong at: reading together. It leans into social reading, with clubs and discussions around books, so it suits people who want conversation more than a private log.

Worth knowing: that same focus means it asks you to take part in a community, which is the opposite of what some people want from a tracker.

Hardcover

Strong at: being a reader-focused Goodreads alternative. It offers a catalogue, shelves and social features in a newer service that presents itself as friendlier to readers and to people who want to take their data with them.

Worth knowing: it is an online account service with a community, so it fits best if you like a social library and want something different from Goodreads.

Ribbon

Strong at: being private and simple. There is no account, no AI and no social feed. Your library stays on your phone, you can import a Goodreads or StoryGraph CSV in one tap, and the library can be shown as a shelf of spines. The yearly goal is a tower that gains a block for every finished book, and you can share a Year in Books card if you choose to.

Ribbon is a good fit if you want a personal reading log, you are uneasy about handing a reading history to an online service, you want to leave Goodreads without losing your shelves, or you like a clean, calm app with a timer and a goal.

Ribbon is not for you if you want a social feed, friends' reviews, book clubs or recommendations based on what other people read. It does not have them on purpose. It is also Android only and English only, so there is no iPhone version, and it is free with ads rather than ad-free.

How to choose

  • Want to see what your friends read and talk about books: Goodreads, Hardcover or Fable.
  • Want deep statistics and mood-based discovery: The StoryGraph.
  • Want a private log on your phone with no account: Ribbon.
  • Not sure: export your Goodreads library once, import it into the apps you are curious about and see which one you open the next day. All of these can take a CSV or give you your data, and Ribbon's switching guide shows the steps.

Goodreads, The StoryGraph, Bookmory, Fable and Hardcover are trademarks of their respective owners. Ribbon is not affiliated with any of them.